Can I make permanent employees redundant while I have agency staff carrying out similar roles?

It’s been another busy week at The HR Booth, where we have been solving customer problems and helping with HR related enquiries.

Here’s another question we’ve been asked to respond to this week.

Question

Can I make permanent employees redundant while I have agency staff carrying out similar roles?

Answer

If you make permanent employees redundant while retaining agency staff in your business to carry out the same or similar work, it raises the question of whether or not the redundancies are genuine or necessary.

You will need to demonstrate that you require fewer people to carry out this type of work, and this could be difficult if you continue to use agency workers.  If you can demonstrate that the agency workers are only used in specific circumstances, perhaps where there is a limited requirement for certain work to be carried out short-term and that your permanent employees are not required in those roles as part of the long-term plans for the business, you could justify redundancies on that basis.

Remember, if you have 20 or more people being made redundant, you will need to consult for at least 30 days, and if it’s 100 or more staff, a minimum of 45 days consultation is required.

The agency question may come up during a consultation, so you will need to consider this when responding to people during your consultation meetings.

If you would like further information on redundancies, please get in touch.

How to Manage Workforce on Demand Effectively

How to Manage Workforce on Demand Effectively

With more and more businesses requiring specialised expertise and the need for greater flexibility, there has been a sharp rise in the use of on-demand workforce planning. This approach is cost effective, flexible and allows companies to carefully acquire talent to...

The need for lifelong learning in HR employees

The need for lifelong learning in HR employees

It’s important that HR employees embrace lifelong learning. HR is a complex field and it’s one which requires a great deal of knowledge and expertise to be successful in. However, it’s about much more than simply acquiring a position; to have a good career in HR you...

What Happens when an Employee is not Eligible for SMP?

What Happens when an Employee is not Eligible for SMP?

We get asked HR related questions every day and each week we will be sharing our top question of the week that we have been asked here at The HR Booth. This week we answer the question "What happens if an employee is not eligible for SMP?" Question We had a girl who...

Is there really freedom of speech in the workplace?

Is there really freedom of speech in the workplace?

Freedom of speech is a fundamental human right that is enshrined in many national and international laws and declarations. However, when it comes to freedom of speech in the workplace, this right can be a bit more complicated.     We take a closer look at...

The Spiral Staircase Approach to Employee Career Management

The Spiral Staircase Approach to Employee Career Management

We investigate the spiral staircase approach to employee management. That all-important career ladder may feel like a rush to the top, with each step moving closer to the pinnacle of power, but this isn't the case in the modern workplace. Careers are a far more...

Carer Positive

Carer Positive

As it is National Carers Week we thought it would be good to share some useful information regarding positive steps employers can take to support employees who may have to look after relatives. This week, Alistair attended the Kitemark launch in conjunction with Carer...