Extending Probation Period: Is It Legal?

Extending probation period can be a tricky area for employers. While probation gives you valuable time to assess whether a new hire is the right fit, sometimes the initial period just isn’t long enough to make a confident decision. Perhaps performance has been inconsistent, training was delayed, or the role has evolved since the employee started.

In short, yes, you can extend a probation period. But before you decide to extend, it’s important to understand the legal and contractual considerations involved — and the steps you should take to ensure the process is fair, compliant, and well-communicated.

What is a probation period?

A probation is a set period of time an employer gives to evaluate a new employee’s suitability to the role and the workplace. While interviews can hint at a candidate’s suitability, the real test is seeing them perform the role and meet the expected standards in practice. Therefore, a lot of employers set a trial period at the beginning of employment to give them time to evaluate if they can be a permanent member of staff.

How long is a probation period?

There are no specific employment laws that set a fixed length for probation periods. However, the most common duration is between three and six months. This gives managers enough time to carry out regular performance reviews and make a more informed decision. At the end of this period, employers will typically either confirm the employee in their role, end their employment, or extend the probation period.

There are no strict rules on how long a probation can be extended — this is at the employer’s discretion. However, it is unusual for the extension to exceed the length of the original period.

Common Reasons to extending Probation Period

There are many reasons why managers may want to extend a probation period. The most common reasons include:

  • More time is required to evaluate performance and conduct
  • The employee has been absent throughout most of the trial
  • Avoid a premature decision and save on recruitment and on-boarding costs
  • To provide further training
  • To give the employer as much opportunity as possible to prove they can make it work in the long-term.

How to Inform an employee their probation period has been extended?

Once you have taken the decision to extending probation period, you must make the worker aware as soon as possible. This should be done at their final scheduled review meeting. You must then follow this with a probation period extension letter. This should include:

  • The decision to extend the trial
  • The reason why the decision was made
  • The length you are extending probation period
  • Support available
  • How progress will be reviewed
  • Targets and goals

How to manage a probation extension period

Managing a probation extension effectively is key to giving the employee a fair chance to improve while protecting your business interests. A clear plan, consistent communication, and proper documentation will help ensure the process is fair, compliant, and productive. Here are steps to ensure efficiency during this extension:

  • Set out clear goals and targets to help staff understand expectations and give managers good points of reference.
  • Schedule Regular performance reviews is the best way to monitor and assess performance.
  • Employee Support is essential to make extending probation period successful. You can provide this through training or supervision.

Dismissal during probation

If you have taken the decision to dismiss an employee due to capability or conduct during their probation period, it’s important to follow a fair and lawful process. You must give the employee the opportunity to respond to the accusations. This can be done at a review meeting and a detailed record should be kept of the concerns raised and how they were addressed.

Any dismissal decision should be given to the employee in writing, including the reasons and the termination date. In most cases, they are entitled to at least one week’s notice, unless their contract allows for longer.

Even during probation, employees retain basic statutory rights, such as protection from unlawful discrimination and automatically unfair dismissal. For example, ending employment due to a protected characteristic like pregnancy or disability could breach both.

How The HR Booth can help

At The HR Booth, we regularly advise employers on managing probation periods fairly and lawfully. Whether you need help drafting clear probation clauses, handling performance concerns, or communicating an extension, our expert team can guide you through each step to minimise risk and maintain good employee relations. We can also provide template letters, manager training, and tailored advice to ensure your processes are compliant and consistent.

Contact Us

If you would like support with extending probation period or managing any aspect of the probation process, get in touch with our team today. You can call us on 01383 668 178, or email advice@thehrbooth.co.uk, or complete our online contact form. We’ll be happy to discuss your needs and provide practical, straightforward advice.

Fair Reasons For Dismissal: An Employers Guide

Fair Reasons For Dismissal: An Employers Guide

Under the Employment Rights Act 1996, there are five potentially fair reasons for dismissal. If you are reading this blog, you may be considering dismissing an employee and want to ensure you are handling the situation correctly. Before making any decision, it is...

Dismissal Due to Ill Health: Is It Ever Fair?

Dismissal Due to Ill Health: Is It Ever Fair?

Employees cannot automatically face dismissal due to ill health. However, in some circumstances, an employer may be able to fairly dismiss an employee on capability grounds where their health is affecting their ability to carry out their role. Before reaching this...

Conditional Offers of Employment: Can You Withdraw a Job Offer?

Conditional Offers of Employment: Can You Withdraw a Job Offer?

Many employers assume that making a conditional offer of employment means they can withdraw the offer at any time before the employee starts work. However, a recent Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) case highlights that this is not always the case. The case...

Managing Workplace Grievances in Accounting Firms

Managing Workplace Grievances in Accounting Firms

In many accounting firms, employees work closely together under significant pressure. While this can create high-performing teams, it can also lead to tension when responsibilities become blurred and communication breaks down. We are seeing a growing number of...

How to Develop Leadership Skills in the Workplace

How to Develop Leadership Skills in the Workplace

Professional services firms operate in a fast-paced, client-driven environment where technical expertise is often prioritised. However, one of the biggest challenges employers face is that high-performing individuals are promoted into management roles without the...

Bank Holiday Entitlement: What Employers Need To Know

Bank Holiday Entitlement: What Employers Need To Know

The Spring bank holiday is coming up and we are getting a lot of questions around bank holiday entitlement. It is important to encourage your staff to take their annual leave to take a well earned rest and avoid burnout. However, your are not automatically required to...