Dismissal Due to Ill Health: Is It Ever Fair?

Employees cannot automatically face dismissal due to ill health. However, in some circumstances, an employer may be able to fairly dismiss an employee on capability grounds where their health is affecting their ability to carry out their role. Before reaching this stage, employers should follow a fair process, obtain appropriate medical advice, and carefully consider alternatives such as reasonable adjustments or changes to duties.

Dismissal should always be treated as a last resort, with the employee’s wellbeing and individual circumstances considered throughout the process.

In this article, we look at when dismissal due to ill health may be lawful, the process employers should follow, and common mistakes to avoid.

Dismissal Due to Ill Health

As mentioned above, you may take the decision to dismiss an employee due to lack of capability. You must clearly show that you followed the right procedures and acted reasonably in treating the long-term illness as a valid reason for dismissal. Each case depends on the circumstances and this should be a last resort.

What Is a Capability Dismissal?

A capability dismissal occurs when an employee is unable to carry out their role to the required standard due to reasons outside of misconduct. This can relate to factors such as performance, qualifications, or health. In cases involving ill health, capability concerns usually arise when an employee’s medical condition affects their ability to perform their duties or attend work regularly.

Dismissal on capability grounds should not be confused with disciplinary action. If an employee is absent due to a genuine health condition, employers should approach the situation with care and support rather than treating it as misconduct.

Capability issues linked to ill health can arise in different ways. For example, an employee may be absent for an extended period due to a serious illness, or they may have frequent periods of short-term absence that are impacting their ability to carry out their role consistently.

Before considering dismissal due to ill health, employers should take steps to fully understand the situation.

What Should Employers Do Before Considering Dismissal?

If you are considering dismissing one of your employees due to long-term sickness absence, you must investigate the possibilities of them being able to return to the office within a reasonable time. Therefore, you must follow a fair procedure. This includes:

  • Consult with your employee
  • hold welfare meetings
  • get a medical report from your employees GP. You must get their permission before you do this and they have the right to see their report before you do.
  • seek Occupational Health input
  • Look at reasonable adjustments such as alternative roles, hours, workplace adaptions, and phased return
  • Look at the possibility of ill-health retirement

As an employer, you must find out the medical position and consult with your employee before deciding if dismissal due to ill health is appropriate.

Why Occupational Health Reports Matter

When managing long-term sickness absence, employers should avoid making assumptions about an employee’s health or their ability to return to work. This is where Occupational Health support can play an important role.

An Occupational Health report provides independent medical guidance to help employers better understand an employee’s condition and how it may be impacting their work. It can offer valuable insight that supports fair decision-making and helps employers explore options before considering dismissal.

An Occupational Health assessment may help answer questions such as:

  • Is the employee currently fit to carry out their role?
  • Is a return to work likely, and if so, when?
  • Are there adjustments that could support them in returning?
  • Does the condition meet the definition of a disability under the Equality Act?
  • Would temporary changes to duties or working patterns help?
  • Is redeployment into an alternative role worth considering?

While an Occupational Health report does not make the decision for an employer, it can provide important information that helps guide the next steps and reduce the risk of unfair dismissal or discrimination claims.

Could the Employee’s Condition Be a Disability?

Before making any decisions on dismissal due to ill health, employers should consider whether an employee’s health condition could amount to a disability under the Equality Act 2010. Conditions that have a substantial and long-term impact on a person’s ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities may be classed as a disability. This could include physical health conditions, long-term illnesses, or mental health conditions such as anxiety or depression.

If a condition meets this definition, employers have a legal duty to consider reasonable adjustments and take extra care when managing absence or capability concerns. Failure to do so could create a risk of disability discrimination claims.

Common Employer Mistakes to Avoid

We’ve seen too many time, employers making mistakes before reaching out to us for help. This includes:

  • dismissing too quickly
  • failing to obtain medical evidence
  • ignoring Occupational Health advice
  • poor documentation
  • failing to consider adjustments
  • inconsistent treatment

Failing to follow the right procedures can lead you to an employment tribunal. Our team of experts are always here to help to ensure you are on the right side of the law.

Final Thoughts

Managing long-term sickness absence can be challenging for employers. While dismissal due to ill health can be fair in some situations, employers should treat it as a last resort. Taking medical advice, considering reasonable adjustments and following a fair process can help reduce legal risk and support better outcomes for everyone involved.

If you’re managing a complex sickness absence case and need support, our HR consultants can guide you through the process.

How to Manage Poor Performance at Work

How to Manage Poor Performance at Work

Poor performance can be frustrating for managers, colleagues and the employee themselves. When an employee is not meeting expectations, it can affect productivity, team morale and the overall performance of the business. However, simply telling someone to improve is...

Employee Onboarding Checklist

Employee Onboarding Checklist

Recruitment does not finish when the candidate accepts the job. The period between accepting an offer and completing the first few months of employment can have a significant impact on how quickly someone settles into the organisation. First impressions are not just a...

Autumn Budget: how this affects UK businesses

Autumn Budget: how this affects UK businesses

Chancellor John Healey announced the Autumn budget promising ‘‘breathing space’’ for businesses. Key updates included increases to national living wage and NMW, new rules on wage transparency, a cash injection to apprenticeships, non-complete clause reforms and...

6 Month Probation Period Law UK: Employer Guide

6 Month Probation Period Law UK: Employer Guide

With significant changes to UK employment law on the horizon, many employers have been asking us about the new 6 month probation period law UK and what it means for their business. Probation periods have always played an important role in helping employers assess...

How to Retain Staff

How to Retain Staff

The busiest time of year for recruitment is approaching, and we are getting a lot of enquiries on how to retain staff. With more businesses competing for the best people, how do you make sure your business is their first choice?  Recruitment isn’t just about filling a...

Common Leadership Challenges in Hospitality

Common Leadership Challenges in Hospitality

The hospitality industry is fast-paced, people-focused and often operates under significant pressure. Managers are expected to balance customer expectations, staffing levels, employee performance and day-to-day operations, often while working evenings, weekends and...